Skip to content
[CRO Course] Module 3: Product Discovery & Collection Strategy

3.3 Search Best Practices

On this page

When someone types "gold engagement ring" or "monogrammed wallet" into your search bar, they're telling you exactly what they want. Site search users convert at 4x higher rates than browsers—making search one of your most valuable conversion tools.

But for personalization stores, search has unique challenges. Customers search for specific combinations like "rose gold necklace with birthstone" or "engraved leather portfolio." If your search can't handle these queries, you lose high-intent buyers who already know what they want.

What Search Results Should Show

Every search result needs the same key information as your collection pages:

  • Product image (show personalized example when possible)
  • "Starting at" price with customization cost indicator
  • Production time ("Ships in 3-5 days" or "Made to order: 2 weeks")
  • Star rating with review count (not just stars—show "4.8 ★ (128 reviews)")
  • Customization indicator ("Engravable" or "✨ Personalize")

When customers search, they're further along in their buying journey. Give them everything they need to click through confidently.

🔍 Anatomy of a Great Search Experience
Every element helps customers find and trust what they're looking for
SMART AUTOCOMPLETE
🔍 annivers|
💍
Anniversary Name Ring
Starting at $129
📁
Anniversary Gifts
47 products
📿
Anniversary Date Necklace
Starting at $89

Shows actual products with images & prices, not just keywords

Suggests categories like "Anniversary Gifts" for browsing
BESTSELLER
✨ Personalize
💍
"Sarah ♥ Mike"
⏱ Ships in 3-5 days
Custom Engraved Anniversary Ring
★★★★★
4.9
(247 reviews)
Starting at
$149
Engraving included
Social Proof
BESTSELLER

Timeline
SHIPS IN X DAYS

Trust Signal
RATING + COUNT


Customizable
✨ PERSONALIZE

Sample Preview
"SARAH ♥ MIKE"

Clear Pricing
STARTING AT $X
✓ What makes this search experience work:
Autocomplete shows real products with prices, not just keywords. Search results display everything customers need to decide: customization options, production time, social proof, and clear pricing—before they even click through.

Autocomplete That Actually Helps

Good autocomplete reduces typing and guides customers toward products you carry.

Include Personalization Terms

Your autocomplete should suggest:

  • Product + customization: "Custom name necklace," "Engraved wedding bands"
  • Occasions: "Anniversary gifts," "Graduation presents"
  • Recipients: "Gifts for mom," "Corporate gifts"

This helps customers who know what they want but aren't sure how you categorize it.

Show Products, Not Just Keywords

As customers type, show actual product suggestions with small images and prices—not just text matches. Seeing "Gold Name Necklace - Starting at $89" is more useful than just seeing "gold necklace" as a suggestion.

Appear Fast

Autocomplete should start showing suggestions after 2-3 characters. Any slower and customers finish typing before help arrives.

Handling Personalization-Specific Searches

When Someone Searches "Personalized"

If everything you sell is customizable, searching "personalized necklace" shouldn't return different results than "necklace."

Two approaches:

  1. Treat "personalized," "custom," and "engraved" as synonyms that don't filter results—just show all relevant products
  2. Add a note above results: "All our products can be personalized—showing all necklaces"

Either way, don't let "personalized" as a search term create confusion.

Searching by Customization Type

Some customers search for the customization itself: "engravable gifts" or "photo upload jewelry."

Make sure customization types are searchable. Tag products with terms like:

  • "Engravable," "Text engraving"
  • "Photo upload," "Picture jewelry"
  • "Monogram," "Initials"

When someone searches "photo gifts," they should find products that accept photo uploads.

Occasion-Based Searches

"Anniversary gift" and "retirement present" are common searches for gift-focused stores.

What to show:

  • Curated results for that occasion (bestsellers, staff picks)
  • Occasion-specific filters above results ("For Her," "For Him," "Under $100")
  • Delivery timing if relevant ("Arrives by [date]")

Treat occasion searches as high-intent—these customers know the "why," they just need the "what."

Synonyms and Typos

Your search should handle how customers actually type, not just perfect spelling.

Map Common Synonyms

Connect terms that mean the same thing:

  • "Personalized" = "custom" = "engraved"
  • "Necklace" = "pendant" = "chain"
  • "Briefcase" = "portfolio" = "laptop bag"
  • "Mom" = "mother" = "mum"

Forgive Typos

Common misspellings shouldn't return zero results:

  • "Dimond" → Diamond
  • "Earings" → Earrings
  • "Anniversery" → Anniversary

Most search apps handle basic typos automatically, but test your common product terms.

When Search Returns Nothing

Empty results kill momentum. Never just show "No results found."

Better approach:

  • "We couldn't find [search term]. Did you mean [suggestion]?"
  • Show related products: "You might like these..."
  • Suggest browsing: "Try our [relevant category] collection"
  • Offer help: "Can't find what you need? Contact us for custom requests"

For personalization stores, that last option matters—you might be able to create exactly what they're searching for.

Mobile Search

Over half your searches happen on phones. Make it easy.

Prominent Search Bar

Put your search icon in the header where thumbs naturally tap. When tapped, expand to a full search bar with autocomplete.

Drawer-Style Filters

When customers want to filter search results, use a slide-up drawer (like in section 3.2). Include a sticky "Apply" button—never auto-submit on mobile.

Keep Search Context

If someone searches "silver earrings," views a product, then taps back—they should return to their search results, not the homepage. Losing search context forces customers to start over.

Search Tools for Shopify

Most Shopify themes include basic search, but personalization stores often need more.

Options to consider:

  • Shopify Search & Discovery (free) — Good starting point, handles basic autocomplete
  • Searchanise — Better autocomplete with product previews
  • Boost Product Filter & Search — Advanced filtering and synonyms

The right choice depends on your catalog size. Start with free options, upgrade if you hit limitations.

Quick Checklist

  • [ ] Search results show image, price, production time, and reviews
  • [ ] Autocomplete suggests products with images, not just keywords
  • [ ] "Personalized" and "custom" searches work sensibly
  • [ ] Customization types (engravable, photo upload) are searchable
  • [ ] Common typos and synonyms return results
  • [ ] Empty results offer alternatives and help options
  • [ ] Mobile search is prominent and keeps context when navigating back
  • [ ] Occasion searches ("anniversary gift") return relevant, curated results

Key Takeaways

Search users already know what they want—your job is to help them find it fast. Show the same key information in search results that you show on collection pages: price, production time, customization options, and reviews.

Handle personalization-specific searches thoughtfully. "Personalized necklace" shouldn't confuse your search, and "engravable gifts" should return products that can be engraved.

When search fails, recover gracefully. Suggestions, related products, and a path to contact you can save a sale that would otherwise be lost.

Next up: Gift guides and occasion-based navigation that turn browsers into buyers.

About the author

avatar.png__PID:d8d98c71-f999-403e-8220-9ebd3859864a

Hi, I’m Monica Nguyen, Marketing Manager at TailorKit, where I specialize in driving eCommerce growth, building impactful brands, and enhancing user retention. With years of experience in the ecom - Shopify field, CRO and personalization-on-demand industry, I’m passionate about helping merchants unlock their store’s full potential. Through my articles, I share actionable tips, proven strategies, and the latest industry insights to help you stay ahead of trends, optimize your store’s performance, and confidently grow your personalization-on-demand business.

Connect me via 👉🏻LinkedIn so we can directly share and talk more and more. I'll be so delighted to connect and support you! 💚